Exploración de los Manipulation Check

Man Check differences by intervention

Models Man Check

Fonasa

  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Moral trust (MDMT) Moral trust (MDMT)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 3.30 ***
(0.07)		 2.46 ***
(0.15)		 2.92 ***
(0.06)		 2.44 ***
(0.13)		 3.19 ***
(0.06)		 3.13 ***
(0.13)
Ai Disclosure (Ex ante) 0.48 ***
(0.10)		 0.20
(0.11)		 0.12
(0.09)		 -0.04
(0.09)		 -0.15
(0.08)		 -0.17
(0.09)
Man. Check Ai Disclosure 0.30 ***
(0.05)		 0.17 ***
(0.04)		 0.02
(0.04)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.042 / 0.040 0.109 / 0.106 0.004 / 0.002 0.034 / 0.030 0.007 / 0.005 0.008 / 0.004
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001
  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Moral trust MDMT Moral trust MDMT Moral trust McKnight Moral trust McKnight Functional trust MDMT Functional trust MDMT Functional trust McKnight Functional trust McKnight
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 6.57 ***
(0.13)		 7.96 ***
(0.31)		 2.94 ***
(0.06)		 2.17 ***
(0.14)		 2.81 ***
(0.06)		 1.73 ***
(0.14)		 2.80 ***
(0.06)		 1.67 ***
(0.15)		 2.77 ***
(0.06)		 1.77 ***
(0.14)		 2.60 ***
(0.06)		 1.42 ***
(0.15)
Control humano (Ex post) 0.74 ***
(0.18)		 1.10 ***
(0.20)		 0.00
(0.08)		 -0.20 *
(0.09)		 0.02
(0.09)		 -0.26 **
(0.09)		 0.06
(0.09)		 -0.23 *
(0.09)		 0.03
(0.09)		 -0.23 *
(0.09)		 0.08
(0.09)		 -0.23 *
(0.09)
Man. Check Control humano -0.46 ***
(0.10)		 0.26 ***
(0.04)		 0.36 ***
(0.04)		 0.37 ***
(0.05)		 0.33 ***
(0.04)		 0.39 ***
(0.04)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.030 / 0.029 0.073 / 0.069 0.000 / -0.002 0.066 / 0.063 0.000 / -0.002 0.118 / 0.114 0.001 / -0.001 0.117 / 0.113 0.000 / -0.002 0.101 / 0.097 0.002 / -0.000 0.130 / 0.127
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001
  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Moral trust MDMT Moral trust MDMT Moral trust McKnight Moral trust McKnight Functional trust MDMT Functional trust MDMT Functional trust McKnight Functional trust McKnight
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 6.58 ***
(0.13)		 4.39 ***
(0.43)		 2.94 ***
(0.06)		 1.48 ***
(0.19)		 2.76 ***
(0.06)		 1.46 ***
(0.20)		 2.79 ***
(0.06)		 1.53 ***
(0.21)		 2.72 ***
(0.06)		 1.38 ***
(0.20)		 2.59 ***
(0.06)		 1.43 ***
(0.21)
Performance (Ex post) 0.74 ***
(0.18)		 0.42 *
(0.19)		 0.00
(0.08)		 -0.21 *
(0.08)		 0.13
(0.09)		 -0.06
(0.09)		 0.09
(0.09)		 -0.10
(0.09)		 0.13
(0.09)		 -0.07
(0.09)		 0.09
(0.09)		 -0.08
(0.09)
Man. Check Performance 0.74 ***
(0.14)		 0.50 ***
(0.06)		 0.44 ***
(0.06)		 0.42 ***
(0.07)		 0.45 ***
(0.06)		 0.40 ***
(0.07)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.031 / 0.029 0.081 / 0.077 0.000 / -0.002 0.114 / 0.110 0.004 / 0.002 0.086 / 0.083 0.002 / -0.000 0.071 / 0.067 0.005 / 0.003 0.093 / 0.089 0.002 / 0.000 0.062 / 0.059
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001

SAE

  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Functional trust (McKnight) Functional trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 4.02 ***
(0.09)		 1.85 ***
(0.26)		 3.14 ***
(0.06)		 0.95 ***
(0.14)		 3.30 ***
(0.06)		 1.51 ***
(0.15)		 3.15 ***
(0.06)		 1.23 ***
(0.15)
Algorithmic disclosure (Ex ante) 0.13
(0.13)		 -0.03
(0.13)		 0.12
(0.09)		 -0.05
(0.07)		 0.11
(0.09)		 -0.02
(0.08)		 0.09
(0.08)		 -0.06
(0.07)
Man. Check Algorithm 0.70 ***
(0.08)		 0.70 ***
(0.04)		 0.58 ***
(0.05)		 0.62 ***
(0.05)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.002 / -0.000 0.136 / 0.132 0.004 / 0.002 0.337 / 0.334 0.004 / 0.002 0.232 / 0.229 0.002 / 0.000 0.266 / 0.264
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001
  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Functional trust (McKnight) Functional trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 3.82 ***
(0.09)		 1.41 ***
(0.25)		 3.11 ***
(0.06)		 0.79 ***
(0.14)		 3.24 ***
(0.06)		 1.23 ***
(0.15)		 3.11 ***
(0.06)		 1.16 ***
(0.15)
Situational information (Ex ante) 0.55 ***
(0.13)		 0.36 **
(0.12)		 0.18 *
(0.09)		 -0.01
(0.07)		 0.24 **
(0.08)		 0.08
(0.07)		 0.17 *
(0.08)		 0.01
(0.07)
Man. Check Situational information 0.78 ***
(0.08)		 0.75 ***
(0.04)		 0.65 ***
(0.05)		 0.63 ***
(0.05)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.032 / 0.030 0.194 / 0.191 0.008 / 0.006 0.377 / 0.375 0.015 / 0.013 0.295 / 0.292 0.008 / 0.006 0.274 / 0.271
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001
  Objective knowledge Objective knowledge Subjective knowledge Subjective knowledge Functional trust (McKnight) Functional trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight) Moral trust (McKnight)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 4.29 ***
(0.10)		 1.20 ***
(0.32)		 3.16 ***
(0.06)		 0.95 ***
(0.19)		 3.32 ***
(0.06)		 1.26 ***
(0.19)		 3.19 ***
(0.06)		 1.16 ***
(0.18)
Human control (Ex post) 0.10
(0.13)		 -0.14
(0.13)		 0.17 *
(0.08)		 0.00
(0.07)		 0.20 *
(0.08)		 0.05
(0.08)		 0.17 *
(0.08)		 0.02
(0.07)
Man. Check Human control 0.92 ***
(0.09)		 0.66 ***
(0.05)		 0.61 ***
(0.05)		 0.60 ***
(0.05)
Observations 514 514 514 514 514 514 514 514
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.001 / -0.001 0.171 / 0.167 0.008 / 0.006 0.235 / 0.232 0.012 / 0.010 0.207 / 0.203 0.009 / 0.007 0.212 / 0.209
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001

Modelos consolidades

  Objective knowledge (Ex-pos) Subjective knowledge (Ex-pos) Moral trust MDMT (Ex-pos) Moral trust McKnight (Ex-pos) Functional trust MDMT (Ex-pos) Functional trust McKnight (Ex-pos)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 5.06 ***
(0.79)		 0.72 *
(0.35)		 0.35
(0.36)		 0.48
(0.39)		 0.24
(0.37)		 0.27
(0.38)
Human control (Ex-pos) 1.12 ***
(0.18)		 -0.18 *
(0.08)		 -0.25 **
(0.08)		 -0.22 *
(0.09)		 -0.22 *
(0.09)		 -0.22 *
(0.09)
Performance (Ex-pos) 0.45 *
(0.18)		 -0.16 *
(0.08)		 -0.03
(0.08)		 -0.06
(0.09)		 -0.03
(0.08)		 -0.05
(0.09)
AI disclosure (Ex-ante) 0.05
(0.19)		 0.02
(0.08)		 0.01
(0.09)		 0.14
(0.09)		 0.06
(0.09)		 0.10
(0.09)
Man. Check Human control -0.39 ***
(0.09)		 0.26 ***
(0.04)		 0.35 ***
(0.04)		 0.37 ***
(0.04)		 0.33 ***
(0.04)		 0.38 ***
(0.04)
Man. Check performance 0.61 ***
(0.14)		 0.46 ***
(0.06)		 0.43 ***
(0.07)		 0.42 ***
(0.07)		 0.45 ***
(0.07)		 0.40 ***
(0.07)
Man. Check AI disclosure 0.27 **
(0.09)		 0.06
(0.04)		 -0.03
(0.04)		 -0.01
(0.04)		 -0.04
(0.04)		 -0.05
(0.04)
Género: Hombre 0.09
(0.17)		 0.01
(0.08)		 0.09
(0.08)		 -0.03
(0.08)		 0.08
(0.08)		 0.03
(0.08)
Edad -0.03 ***
(0.01)		 -0.00
(0.00)		 0.01
(0.00)		 0.00
(0.00)		 0.01
(0.00)		 0.01 *
(0.00)
Educación: Media completa 0.62
(0.55)		 -0.03
(0.25)		 -0.22
(0.26)		 -0.33
(0.27)		 -0.12
(0.26)		 -0.34
(0.27)
Educación: Superior 0.75
(0.54)		 0.07
(0.24)		 -0.13
(0.25)		 -0.32
(0.27)		 -0.01
(0.25)		 -0.30
(0.26)
Observations 512 512 512 512 512 512
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.197 / 0.181 0.186 / 0.170 0.212 / 0.196 0.193 / 0.177 0.200 / 0.185 0.203 / 0.187
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001
  Objective knowledge (Ex post) Subjective knowledge (Ex post) Moral trust McKnight (Ex post) Functional trust McKnight (Ex post)
Predictors Estimates Estimates Estimates Estimates
Intercept 0.46
(0.54)		 0.06
(0.27)		 0.38
(0.30)		 0.35
(0.29)
Human control (Ex post) -0.10
(0.12)		 0.03
(0.06)		 0.07
(0.07)		 0.05
(0.06)
Situational information (Ex ante) 0.29 *
(0.12)		 0.05
(0.06)		 0.05
(0.07)		 -0.02
(0.06)
Algorithmic disclosure (Ex ante) 0.01
(0.12)		 -0.05
(0.06)		 -0.09
(0.07)		 -0.09
(0.06)
Man. Check Human control 0.47 ***
(0.11)		 0.13 *
(0.05)		 0.18 **
(0.06)		 0.19 **
(0.06)
Man. Check Situational information 0.29 **
(0.11)		 0.41 ***
(0.05)		 0.36 ***
(0.06)		 0.31 ***
(0.06)
Man. Check Algorithmic disclosure 0.42 ***
(0.11)		 0.43 ***
(0.05)		 0.33 ***
(0.06)		 0.35 ***
(0.06)
Género: Hombre 0.08
(0.12)		 -0.07
(0.06)		 -0.10
(0.07)		 -0.05
(0.06)
Edad -0.00
(0.01)		 -0.00
(0.00)		 0.00
(0.00)		 0.00
(0.00)
Educación: Media completa -0.25
(0.38)		 0.20
(0.19)		 0.35
(0.21)		 0.24
(0.21)
Educación: Superior -0.08
(0.37)		 0.17
(0.19)		 0.17
(0.21)		 0.08
(0.20)
Observations 512 512 512 512
R2 / R2 adjusted 0.265 / 0.251 0.525 / 0.515 0.410 / 0.398 0.400 / 0.388
* p<0.05   ** p<0.01   *** p<0.001 
                                  GVIF Df GVIF^(1/(2*Df))
control_humano_fonasa         1.188106  1        1.090003
performance_fonasa            1.132481  1        1.064181
ai_disclosure_fonasa          1.245378  1        1.115965
fonasa_man_check_ch           1.215769  1        1.102619
fonasa_man_check_perf         1.273910  1        1.128676
fonasa_man_check_aidisclosure 1.364961  1        1.168315
genero                        1.030051  1        1.014914
edad_num                      1.015161  1        1.007552
education_recoded             1.022155  2        1.005493
                            GVIF Df GVIF^(1/(2*Df))
control_humano          1.042506  1        1.021032
inf_situacional         1.030559  1        1.015164
disclosure              1.030412  1        1.015092
sae_man_check_controlh  1.594980  1        1.262925
sae_man_check_infosit   2.030578  1        1.424984
sae_man_check_algoritmo 2.167216  1        1.472147
genero                  1.029922  1        1.014851
edad_num                1.016126  1        1.008031
education_recoded       1.020191  2        1.005010